TidBITS
 

Wherefore Art Thou, Babel?

TidBITS is translated in a number of languages by teams of volunteers, to whom we owe a tremendous debt of gratitude - check out our Translations page or the "Translations" area of the navigation links on this page to see currently active translations.

We're sometimes asked why we don't use software-based language translation programs to translate TidBITS into other languages automatically. The basic answer is that automated translation tools are very limited. That isn't a put-down: machine translation is an incredibly difficult problem that's much more complicated than a simple word-for-word substitution of terms. Machine translation is undeniably useful under some circumstances - even a word-for-word substitution may help a knowledgeable reader glean some meaning from otherwise-incomprehensible text. But machine translations always lack the clarity and nuance of human translations, and often completely fail to convey the original idea or meaning.

Here's an example. The TidBITS German translation team translated the following MailBIT about EIMS 3.0 from TidBITS 532 into German. We then took the German text and translated it back into English to see how closely the machine-generated English matched the content and meaning of the original English.

We weren't expecting perfection, but, as you can see, the results would be less-than-useful for a professional publication. If you want to have fun, start with one of the German-to-English machine translations (from Systran or Transparent Language) and see if you can understand the MailBIT.

Original English:

Qualcomm Ships EIMS 3.0 -- Qualcomm has shipped Eudora Internet Mail Server (EIMS) 3.0, the latest version of Glenn Anderson's popular email server for the Mac OS. The most significant enhancement in EIMS 3.0 is support for the IMAP 4, which enables users to store messages on the server rather than on users' machines (as happens with the more-common POP3). Current versions of Eudora, Outlook Express, PowerMail, Mulberry, and Netscape Communicator support IMAP on the Macintosh. EIMS 3.0 also offers twice the throughput of version 2.x, enables the administrator to configure the port used for SMTP service (perfect for running EIMS and a mailing list server on the same machine), and other improvements. System requirements include a 68030-based Mac or better with at least 8 MB of RAM and System 7.1 or later with Open Transport 1.1.2 or later, although using IMAP may increase those requirements substantially. EIMS also has a new pricing scheme: new copies cost $400 and upgrades are $150 through mid-August, after which the prices jumps to $500 and $250, respectively. A 60-day demo is available as a 2.3 MB download.

 

German Translation from the TidBITS German team:

EIMS 3.0 von Qualcomm veröffentlicht -- Es gibt jetzt den Eudora Internet Mail Server (EIMS) 3.0 von Qualcomm. Das ist die neueste Version des beliebten E-Mail-Servers für Mac OS von Glenn Anderson. Die wichtigste Verbesserung in EIMS 3.0 ist IMAP 4-Unterstützung. Damit kann der Anwender Nachrichten auf dem Server speichern und nicht auf der lokalen Festplatte, wie es bei dem ziemlich verbreiteten POP3 der Fall ist. Die aktuellen Versionen von Eudora, Outlook Express, PowerMail, Mulberry und Netscape Communicator unterstützen IMAP auf dem Macintosh. Neben weiteren Verbesserungen bietet EIMS 3.0 den doppelten Durchsatz im Vergleich zur Version 2.x und der Administrator kann den Port einstellen, der für SMTP-Dienste genutzt wird (so ist es problemlos möglich, einen Mailinglistenserver und EIMS auf dem selben Rechner laufen zu lassen). Das Programm erfordert einen 68030-Mac oder besser mit mindestens 8 MB RAM unter System 7.1 oder höher. Weiterhin ist Open Transport 1.1.2 (oder neuer) nötig. Die Verwendung von IMAP kann allerdings dazu führen, dass diese Anforderungen noch nach oben geschraubt werden. Auch der Preis für EIMS hat sich geändert: Bis Mitte August kostet eine neue Version $400 und das Update $150. Danach ändern sich die Preise auf $500 bzw. $250. Es gibt eine 60-Tage-Demo als 2.3 MB großen Download.

 

German-to-English Translation from Systran:
(Compare to the original English version)

EIMS 3,0 of agony COMM publishes -- there is now the Eudora InterNet mail server (EIMS) 3,0 of agony COMM. That is the newest version of the popular E-Mail server for Mac OS von Glenn Anderson one. The most important improvement in EIMS 3,0 is IMAP 4-Unterstuetzung. Thus the user can store messages on the server and not on the local fixed disk, how it is with the rather spread POP3 the case. The current versions of Eudora, Outlook express, PowerMail, Mulberry and Netscape Communicator support IMAP on the Macintosh. Apart from further improvements EIMS 3,0 offers the double throughput in the comparison to the version 2.x and the administrator can the port stop, for SMTP services is used (like that it is problem-free possible to let a mailing list server and a EIMS on the same computer run). The program requires a 68030-Mac or better with at least 8 MT RAM under system 7,1 or more highly. Further open feed 1,1,2 (or more again) is necessary. The use of IMAP can lead however to the fact that these request are screwed still upward. Also the price for EIMS changed: To in the middle of August costs a new version $400 and the update $150. Afterwards the prices on $500 or $250 change. There is a 60-Tage-Demo as 2,3 MT large Download.

 

German-to-English Translation from Transparent Language:
(Compare to the original English version)

EIMS 3.0 of Qualcomm publishes gives -- it now 3.0 of Qualcomm to the Eudora Internet Mail Server (EIMS). That is the newest version of the popular E-Mail-Servers for Mac OS of Glenn Anderson. The most important improvement in EIMS 3.0 is IMAP 4-Unterstützung. Therewith the user messages can store on the Server and not on the local hard disk how it is in the rather common POP3 the case. The current versions of Eudora, outlook express, PowerMail, Mulberry and Netscape Communicator support IMAP on the Macintosh. Next to further improvements, EIMS 3.0 offers doubled can adjust that Durchsatz in comparison with the version 2. the Port, that is used for SMTP-services, to x and the Administrator (is so it problem-free possible, a Mailinglistenserver and EIMS on the same computer run to leave). The program requires a 68030-Mac or better with at least 8 MB RAM under system 7.1 or more highly. Further Open carrier 1.1.2 (or newer) is necessary. The use of IMAP can lead to be sure in addition that these requests are screwed yet towards the top. Also the price for EIMS changed: until middle August a new version costs $400 and the Update $150. after that change the prices on $500 and/or $250. it gives a 60-tage-demo 60-tage-demo day of Download large 60-tage-demo demo as 2.3 MB. change. There is a 60-Tage-Demo as 2,3 MT large Download.

Published 10-Jul-2000 in conjunction with TidBITS 538.